Upgrading OT/ICS Jump Servers for Improved Cybersecurity and Operational Resilience

In partnership with

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this newsletter are solely my own. 

The author and the newsletter are not responsible for any actions taken by individuals or organizations. The content is for educational and informational purposes only and is not tailored to any specific business or situation.

In Operational Technology (OT) and Industrial Control Systems (ICS), jump servers are pivotal in managing access across various security zones, acting as critical gateways between trusted internal networks and more exposed or less secure areas such as the DMZ. As cyber threats become more sophisticated and the convergence of IT and OT environments accelerates, modernizing jump servers is essential to meet evolving security demands and operational requirements.

Why Modernize Jump Servers?

In the world of Operational Technology (OT) and Industrial Control Systems (ICS), jump servers are crucial for managing access across different security zones, bridging trusted internal networks with more exposed or less secure areas, such as DMZs. However, as cyber threats evolve and the integration of IT and OT environments becomes more complex, it is essential to modernize jump servers to meet both security and operational demands.

Traditional Jump Server Limitations

Historically, jump servers relied on basic SSH or RDP connections, offering secure access paths for administrative functions. While effective initially, several key drawbacks have emerged over time, which make a compelling case for modernization:

1. Security Risks: Jump servers can be a single point of failure if compromised. A notable example is the 2015 breach, where a compromised jump server led to one of the largest data breaches in U.S. history, highlighting the severe risks associated with traditional models.

2. Operational Inefficiency: Traditional jump servers often require users to log into multiple systems, which can be time-consuming and cumbersome. This process detracts from operational efficiency, especially as networks expand.

3. Lack of Scalability: As networks grow and more devices come online, the traditional model struggles with complex configurations and management. This lack of scalability can impede growth and flexibility in OT environments.

As many customers continue to rely on Forti VPN or traditional VPNs to access jump servers in their production environments, it’s crucial to address some of the inherent security flaws associated with VPN technology.

Key Security Flaws in VPNs

While VPNs provide remote access, they come with several security vulnerabilities that need attention:

1. All-or-Nothing Network Access: VPNs often grant full network access after authentication, which can allow attackers to move laterally across the network, potentially exposing sensitive resources.

2. Lack of Continuous Monitoring: Once authenticated, VPNs typically do not provide ongoing monitoring of user activity, leaving the network vulnerable to unauthorized actions during the session.

3. Dependency on Internet Connectivity: VPNs require a stable internet connection, which poses challenges for environments intentionally kept offline for security reasons—common in many OT systems.

4. Exposure of Insecure Protocols: VPNs can expose OT protocols such as Modbus or DNP3, which lack inherent security. These protocols become prime targets for exploitation when transmitted over unsecured VPNs.

5. Challenges with Third-Party Access: VPNs usually require software agents for access, which can be impractical for third-party vendors who may use different devices or VPN software, complicating secure access management.

Key Standards and Best Practices for Modernizing OT/ICS Jump Servers

To address these challenges, organizations can adopt the following standards and best practices to modernize jump servers and strengthen cybersecurity:

The Need for Modern Remote Access Solutions in Factories

As manufacturing processes evolve, traditional methods no longer suffice. Modern OT environments require secure, scalable, and efficient remote access solutions, such as Cyolo’s platform for secure remote access, which address these shortcomings.

Modernizing Jump Servers: A Strategic Approach

To adapt to the challenges of today's industrial environments, jump servers must be modernized with enhanced security features. Here’s a breakdown of modern approaches:

1. Zero Trust Architecture

Modern jump servers should be integrated into a Zero Trust framework. This approach ensures that all access requests, regardless of their origin, are authenticated and authorized before being granted, fundamentally shifting away from perimeter-based security models.

2. Cloud-Based Solutions

Cloud directory services, such as Jump Cloud, offer simplified management, scalability, and features like automated scaling and SSH key management, making them ideal for modern OT/ICS environments.

3. Advanced Authentication

Multi-factor authentication (MFA) and two-factor authentication (2FA) can significantly enhance security. Combining these methods with VPNs provides a more secure connection to OT assets.

4. Network Segmentation and Firewalls

By segmenting networks and using modern firewalls, organizations can isolate different operational segments, limiting the impact of potential breaches and preventing lateral movement within the network.

5. Real-Time Monitoring and Logging

Modern jump servers should feature robust logging and continuous monitoring to detect unauthorized access or abnormal behavior in real-time, improving security and aiding compliance.

6. Privileged Access Management (PAM) Integration

Integrating jump servers with PAM systems reduces the risks associated with shared accounts or passwords, allowing for individual accountability and better security practices.

7. Automated Patching and Updates

Ensuring that jump servers are regularly patched and updated is crucial in OT environments. Automated patch management ensures that known vulnerabilities are addressed promptly, reducing the attack surface.

8. Session Recording and Monitoring

Recording and monitoring all sessions conducted through jump servers provides valuable audit trails for compliance, incident response, and security analysis.

9. Least Privilege Access

Implementing least privilege access ensures that users only have the minimum level of access necessary to perform their job functions, mitigating the risk of unauthorized access.

Steps to Implement Modern Jump Servers

Successfully modernizing jump servers in an industrial setting requires a methodical approach:

1. Assessment and Planning: Evaluate existing OT/ICS infrastructure, assess the risks, and plan necessary upgrades. Compliance with standards like ISA/IEC 62443 is critical.

2. Choosing the Right Technology: Select solutions that seamlessly integrate with existing SCADA systems, supporting legacy protocols while ensuring modern security features like encryption and 2FA.

3. Implementation: Deploy new technologies with minimal disruption to production, ensuring secure remote access without compromising OT system integrity.

4. Security Enhancements: Implement robust network segmentation, intrusion detection systems, and encryption of data in transit and at rest to safeguard against both external and insider threats.

5. Training and Policy Development: Train staff on cybersecurity awareness, safe jump server use, and recognizing phishing attempts. Develop policies tailored to your facility’s specific operational and security needs.

6. Testing and Validation: Conduct stress tests under real-world conditions to validate the functionality and security of jump servers, ensuring they support operations without risk.

7. Maintenance and Review: Regularly update both hardware and software. Perform reviews and external audits to ensure security measures are up to date and effective.

Conclusion

Modernizing OT/ICS jump servers goes beyond simply upgrading technology—it’s about redefining how security, access, and operational management are approached in industrial environments. By embracing modern strategies, such as Zero Trust, advanced authentication, network segmentation, and automated patching, organizations can significantly enhance security while improving operational efficiency. This modernization not only mitigates the risk of cyber threats but also strengthens the resilience and agility of OT/ICS systems in the face of an increasingly digital world.

Top News of the Week

Here are some quick notes on the ICS/OT cyber security-related items you should be aware of from this week: